If you sell alcohol, tobacco, or cannabis, you know the risks. Selling to a minor – even accidentally – can result in fines, criminal charges, and losing your license. But what happens when someone uses a convincing fake ID or an older sibling’s license? Are you automatically guilty?
Not necessarily. Many states offer what’s called an affirmative defense for businesses that use electronic ID verification. Understanding how it works can protect your business when things go wrong.
An affirmative defense is a legal protection that can get you off the hook even if a sale to a minor technically occurred. You’re essentially saying: “Yes, the sale happened, but I took every reasonable step to prevent it.”
The key word is reasonable. Courts and licensing boards recognize that no system is perfect. A well-made fake ID can fool even experienced staff. An affirmative defense acknowledges this reality and protects businesses that do their due diligence.
Without this protection, selling age-restricted products would be a strict liability situation. The sale itself would be enough to convict you, regardless of how careful you were. Affirmative defense changes that equation.
Simply asking to see an ID isn’t usually enough to claim affirmative defense. Most states require electronic verification – meaning you need to scan the ID, not just glance at it.
Here’s why scanning matters:
An ID scanner reads the encoded data on the barcode or magnetic stripe and compares it against known formats. It verifies the ID hasn’t expired, calculates the holder’s age instantly, and can flag suspicious documents. More importantly, it creates a timestamped record proving you checked.
That record is your evidence. If you’re ever charged with selling to a minor, you can show that at the time of sale, you scanned a valid ID that indicated the buyer was of legal age. This is exactly what affirmative defense laws are designed to protect.
While specific requirements vary by state, most affirmative defense laws share common elements:
The ID must be scanned at the time of sale. Checking someone’s ID last week doesn’t count. Neither does a hand stamp from the door. The person completing the transaction needs to verify age right then.
The ID must be a valid, government-issued document. Typically this means a driver’s license or state ID card. Some states accept passports, military IDs, or other documents – others don’t.
You must also perform a visual check. Scanning alone isn’t enough. Staff should confirm the photo matches the person, the ID doesn’t appear altered, and nothing seems suspicious. Electronic verification and human judgment work together.
Some states require you to retain scan data for a specific period. Utah, for example, limits retention to seven days. Others have different requirements or none at all.
Affirmative defense is not a free pass. Most state laws still require “reasonable diligence” and “good faith” beyond just scanning. The protection typically won’t apply if:
You skipped the scan and just looked at the ID. You accepted an obviously fake or altered document. Your staff didn’t check if the photo matched the customer. The ID was expired. You knew or had reason to believe the buyer was underage.
The scan creates your evidence. Common sense and visual verification complete the defense.
As of now, twelve states have affirmative defense provisions related to ID scanning:
Arizona, Connecticut, Nevada, New York, North Carolina, Ohio, Oregon, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, Texas, Utah, and West Virginia.
Each state’s law has its own requirements, accepted ID types, and conditions. What qualifies you in Ohio may not be sufficient in Texas.
For details on your state’s specific requirements, view our state-by-state ID verification law guide.
Affirmative defense doesn’t guarantee you’ll never face charges. But it gives you a fighting chance when you’ve done everything right and still get burned by a sophisticated fake or a borrowed ID.
The combination of electronic ID scanning and proper staff training is your best protection. Scan every time, check every ID visually, keep your records according to state law and know your state’s requirements.
This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Consult with licensing authorities and legal counsel about ID verification requirements in your jurisdiction.
Schedule a call to learn more
